Find all hotels by Independent in Shelter Island Heights, NY from AED 364

"The view from the room"

"A very nice hotel. The rooms were clean and comfortable. "

"Had a great stay!"

"Location, location..."

"Will go back. Loved the hotel, restaurants and over all property. "

"Very convenient "

"The overnight accommodations were fine. The spa treatments were the highlight of our stay. We were disappointed with the jacuzzi - too many children trying to get in (they didn't) but it was noisy."

"Excellent "

"We have stayed at the Montauk Manor for the holidays many times and find it friendly, peaceful and comfortable."