Find Adventure Hotels in Shelter Island Heights, NY

"I really enjoyed my two-night stay at Montauk Oceanside Suites. It's a very nice, quiet place to stay and also the beach is literally just across the street. Having never stayed there before, I was also very pleased with my room. Lots of nice touches (books, DVDs, chairs outside the room with a little table between them). My room was freshly painted with a comfortable bed and sofa. The dining table was by the window so you could look out at the view while you ate. I brought groceries to cook in the room, so the kitchenette was also a real bonus!"

"Incredible experience from the concierge assistance for check in and dinner reservations through Bridget and Aadil, and the front desk who helped with literally anything we needed or had questions about. The entire staff, wait service, and chef made our dining experience one to remember (Chefs Table highly recommend to reserve for anyone looking for a unique and personable dinner with some interactions). They truly made you feel welcome and did the absolute best to ensure you had the best possible stay. Daksha was extremely accommodating and always checked on us or helped us whenever we crossed paths. We cant wait to go back."

"It was really nice, the tv had basic cable so the kids were able to watch their favorite cartoons! The weather wasn’t on our side this go around but the hotels pool really made the stay. It was clean and well kept. "

"Convenient, great value"

"All good "

"My fiancé and I had a lovely time. "

"Everything was great from checking in to checking out. The rooms were very big and well maintained with a nice view to the waterfront. My only problem was that there was not enough parking at night. The parking area behind the hotel tends to get full, and most time it’s because people double park. It would be nice to have someone from the hotel guide people, or put some sort of markings, because that would allow for more room. Other than that, it was a great stay. "

"we had a room with a balcony that looked out to the ocean. terrific view. lovely property & staff was very friendly"

"Above and beyond what we expected for an off-season stay! Beautifully maintained property, gorgeous view from our room's balcony, kind and helpful staff. Will definitely be back in the near future."