The Best Beach Hotels in Fire Island, NY from AED 547 in 2025

Check availability on Fire Island Beach Hotels

Tonight

Tomorrow

This weekend

Next weekend

Compare Fire Island Beach Hotels room rates, reviews, and availability. Most hotels are fully refundable.

"We stayed one night and this hotel was awesome. First, they allow a 11:30 am check in which is rare. We were visiting friends so we dropped bags off and came back late night but it was convenient be able to do so. The room was immaculate and even though the bathrooms are shared, you get the full bathroom to yourself when you use it. The location is great just outside the ferry terminal. It’s very loud at night but we brought earplugs. Most importantly, staff are very friendly and held on to our...

AED 978 total

includes taxes & fees

4 May - 5 May

Gallery Quadruple Room, 2 Queen Beds | Free WiFi, bed sheets

"It was very comfortable and peaceful. A great place to stay. It's pricey, but everything on the island is these days. The staff are all really friendly and helpful."

AED 625 total

includes taxes & fees

4 May - 5 May

"Gave an extended weekend trip to my sister and brother in law for their 59th birthdays. They had an amazing relaxing time. They are repeat visitors at the Palms because it is second to none on Ocean Beach. Bicycles, beach chairs, umbrellas provided making it stress free. Staff is always accommodating including assisting with luggage at the dock. They took their own boat and the staff still met them and assisted. They had one glitch, the AC in their room suddenly went out (which is...

"My room was lovely, but the exterior areas of the property need better upkeep. Pool was never skimmed or cleaned and deck furniture was covered in pine tree droppings."

AED 646 total

includes taxes & fees

5 May - 6 May

"Great location but room was very dry and no AC in one of the rooms. Very friendly staff"

"This house was very nice, as pictured or better. Clean, no issues checking in or out. Wagon was there as promised, more bikes than promised, lots of beach towels and chairs provided. The house had two wonderful outdoor second story decks with great views of the water and the ferry dock. Location was perfect, so convenient to ferry and market. Two things not great. Although it had an AC unit in every bedroom that all worked fine which made ground floor cool and comfortable, the main living...

"This property is steps away from the ferry, steps away from the beach and steps away from food, drinks and music. We had a great time. Cassie greeted us and made sure we had everything we needed!!!! She also went out of her way to make my daughters 21st birthday special. Highly recommend this property."