Pet-friendly Hotels in Coral Bay

"We stayed at Papaya Moon for two weeks at the beginning of March 2025 in the “Place in the Sun” suite. Simply paradise. The mountaintop views and breezes are heavenly. It is a very private location, surrounded by Sue’s beautiful gardens and the natural beauty of the island. You have your option of lots of outdoor activities – swimming, kayaking, snorkeling in turquoise waters; hiking the many trails that range from challenging to easy-going strolls. Or you can relax on the deck and gaze at sea...

"We loved our stay at this home in Coral Bay. It is located on the quieter side of the island and in short drives to the main beaches and sights. The home is extremely clean, well appointed, and A/C works great. Communication with the property manager, Dwight, was fantastic and he checked in with us throughout our stay to make sure everything was going well. The pool is a little larger than I expected from the pictures which was a nice bonus. Views are phenomenal and we enjoyed just hanging out...

"The views from the decks and pool are some of the best I have ever seen. The house had everything we needed to cook meals, grill, beach towels and beach chairs. Kandace was quick to respond to the questions we had and offered suggestions on grocery shopping and jeep rentals. It was a bit of an adventure getting up to the house but it was so worth it. It truly was a wonderful week spent with friends exploring the beautiful island of St. John."

"Sea shine is a quiet, private, clean and safe place. The view from the patio is outstanding! Theresa had the place well stocked with beach towels, a beach bag, spices and even snorkeling gear. The cost of the rental over NYE was fair.We enjoyed our stay however, we would’ve given 5 stars had the WiFi and the hot tub worked. The WiFi was spotty at best; perhaps not the hosts fault? The hot tub was is need of repair which we notified the host about. Overall, it was lovely and a very pleasant place...

"The views are hands down insane! You won’t find those kind of views anywhere else on the island. Make sure to wake up early to catch the sunrise. The mattress was hard and I believe does need to be replaced along with a couple pillows and the comforter was scratchy. There was no soap in the bathroom pump. We wanted to spend time down by the pool but there was no umbrella for shade. Small things but little things make a difference especially a good bed when you’re there all week. We didn’t...

"We loved our stay here near Coral Bay. The view was incredible and the space was perfect for the two of us. It was the most convenient that the owners provided Beach chairs, towels, a cooler, and floaties for us to use at the beaches each day. The home was clean and we enjoyed using the tv in the evenings after exploring all day. Highly recommend!"

"This dreamy abode had all you could need. Stunning pool with gorgeous, lush, green landscape, cute neighborhood animals all around to greet, along with amazing views of the island. Lorraine was beyond hospitable and helpful and we enjoyed talking with her! "

"WOW! Where to begin! From early on when we booked our reservation at Water & Sky, the hosts, Tony and MaryAnn were in contact with us and remained there every step of the way! It's comforting to know that it's not just a rental company, it's the homeowners making sure that your questions are answered and your needs are met. They were a pleasure to work with! The house itself sits above Coral Bay with an AMAZING view of the harbor and islands beyond! We spent hours out on the decks...