Search Cottages in Shelter Island

"Great place! "

"Cozy and clean hotel. The staff were very nice. We really enjoyed our stay. There is a good breakfast/lunch restaurant across the street. "

"This is a beautiful property with a great location, delicious dining and fun and relaxing entertainment. We stayed on a Thursday night, enjoyed lunch and dinner at Fresh Salt, and then music in the ChooChoo lounge. We love the history of the place, and enjoyed walking the causeway, even in foggy and cool weather on the first day of spring. Our daughter and son-in-law enjoyed the spa, the pool both outdoor and inside. We would stay here again, very friendly and relaxing. Every staff member we met was friendly made us feel welcome. "

"Love the location "

"Fabulous stay! Clean room, great staff! In the middle of a sweet town! Next door to the aquarium ."

"The staff at Baron's was extremely accomodating - from dog friednly room options to placing a crib in our room before arrival for our newborn. Every request was met swiftly and executed well. Highly recommend. Easy to walk to downtown Sag if you don't want to deal with parking, and vast array of amenities on site were lovely. "

"Lovely owners, nice property. "

"The whole experience was ready and kind. "

"The breakfast coffee was sub par. The omelette was very good."