Search Cottages in Shelter Island

"Very clean and adorable place providing all one needs for peace and respite. I would return again."

"My husband and I stayed here for a weekend in September and loved every minute. Cottage was well decorated, very clean and had everything you would need. We loved the outdoor shower and the host was so accommodating and thoughtful. Highly recommend and hope to return soon. "

"This was an amazing place to stay. Beautiful property and EXCELLENT hosts! Thank you!"

"Great last minute stay with our pup. House offered ability to have our dog and a back yard for him to play."

"I couldn’t wait to leave a review…to rave about this house. Our hosts met us upon arrival and took the time to show us around. The house was absolutely gorgeous, spacious with state-of-the-art, appliances, tech, and beautifully decorated with attention paid to every detail. It was spa-like. Since the weather was mild for November, they even set up the outdoor patio set and fire pit for us. The house had everything we needed. We know the area so we knew it was conveniently located to shops,...

"We all liove the various Connecticut shore towns, and Ild Lyme was delightful. We revisited some favorite spots, and discovered a few new ones. The vintage appliances were particularly nice to find, and looking at old photos, we realized that the original cottage was really 100 years old!"

"We enjoyed our stay. The location was great and the owner was available for questions. "

"Nice place in quiet neighborhood with great owner. "

"The location was perfect. Very comfortable."

"A wonderful cottage in a great community at Point O Woods Beach. The host was incredibly helpful, responsive and did everything to make our stay a memorable one. Thank you so much!"

"A five star review is not enough for this beautiful property! It is so well appointed, with everything you can possibly imagine to make your stay nothing less than perfect! It is an immaculate place that is decorated beautifully and the moment you open the door here you know you’ve chosen a charming and beautiful place to stay. The owner, Bill, was readily available prior to arriving to answer any questions we had. Even after we were here, he was in communication with us, which is always a...