Search Guest Houses in Shelter Island

"Great location! On the bay but walking distance to town "

"The room was clean. The property was well kept. The town is a block away so you can walk to everything."

"First I want to sincerely apologize my 3 year girl got really sick on the last day. But overall experience was amazing my favorite thing about this hotel was the staff how they how they were with us how they were my daughter when she was playing with them do sincerely appreciate that made her birthday week even better."

"Good "

"Kenny isn't the Tipp, he's the Tops"

"Spa was fantastic, rooms are nothing extravagant but clean and well maintained. Everyone was polite, great stay"

"The staff was kind and very hospitable. Very beautiful environment and clean place to stay. "

"Unable to rate beachfront, as our stay was off season , but, WHAT A VIEW!"

"The owner was so helpful and friendly. When our car wouldn't start due to a dead battery, he called a friend to drive over to give us a jump (since the owner's car was a hybrid and he couldn't access his battery). The grounds are beautifully landscaped with lots of blooming trees and flowers. It's very conveniently located with a great cafe across the street."