Search Aparthotels in Shelter Island

"I love this property! I stayed for one night and there was a comedian and a lot of activity in the hotel which made for a great night! My only complaint is the bed! It was probably the least comfortable bed I have ever slept in a hotel. I had a horrible night sleep as the mattress was terrible! The room and amenities are all top notch! I am not a fan of the blue toilet water as a cleaner… but just my personal opinion. "

"Lovely area easy check in clean rooms amazing view "

"We have been staying at the Bentley, four one week to times since November as it is very conveniently located a a couple minutes away from our house being remodeled. We appreciate the very “generous sized mini apartments” rooms offered there making our extended stays, hyper comfortable! But what truly makes us always coming back is the wonderful staff( Renso, Joe and Sergei, all VERY professionally managed by Virna. The only negative part for me are the bulbs chosen in the living room: they are neon like in color and we prefer soft/warm light. So we bring our own bulbs and everybody’s happy!"

"Amazing place! "

"Outstanding "

"Loved the location, staff and size of the room."

"Great hotel experience at Pier Blue Guesthouse. Everything was perfect. I stayed over for a few days and absolutely loved in. The rooms are very clean, and quiet. Super comfortable beds. One of the rooms i stayed in had an ocean theme with a Sea Shell carved sink! Such great touches. The staff was terrific. Both managers Rick an Sima were so welcoming, friendly and kind. I even had great conversations with Sima and Rick. The whole experience made me feel so comfortable, and is the definition of a home away from home. Absolutely A , 5 Stars. I really look forward to staying there again."

"We had an unexpected trip to sag harbor and had to reserve quickly. The property was clean very pretty and quaint. The room was comfortable and quaint as well. "

"Its clean and i love it"