Historic Hotels in Central Eleuthera

"Amazing privacy with a stunning beach. Beautiful reef just 100 yards offshore. Night views are amazing. And the property itself is phenomenal - perfect in every way for a couple. Clean, good modern amenities, quiet and private. The only "complaint" is that the nightime biting insects are nothing to joke about. Make sure to have insect repellent and some Neosporin or similar - in the evenings they are just above the grass. "

"My wife and her bestie turned 50 and 40 this past fall. Her husband and I took them to them to Eleuthera to relax and celebrate. Bonefish Barbi’s is the perfect secluded getaway. Love it!"

"The Sea Spray cottage was accurately represented in the listing. We saw sting rays from the deck, and watched every sunrise and sunset. The house was stocked with the basics, but also had books and maps of the island beaches and snorkeling spots, left by the owners or past guests. We contributed a map to the pile when we left. Couldn’t have asked for more. It was gorgeous and felt completely private, with the safety of knowing the owner was close by if needed. Highly recommend. "

"We had an amazing stay at DaddyJoe's, Tiffany and her team were so welcoming and made us feel right at home right away! Special shout-out to Sandy and all the restaurant and bar staff, so warm and friendly! Fantastic food (fish tacos!!) and delicious drinks! We caught the sunset on the beach across the street two nights in a row. We even got upgraded to a 2-bedroom suite! We would definitely stay here again in a heartbeat and recommend it to everyone we know!"

"This is an incredible getaway. The house has everything we needed to cook and bake, including a grill. There are times when the power on the island is out so the grill was really handy. The beach is one of the most beautiful places I’ve ever seen and most days we were the only ones there. Jethro was always available if we needed him and very friendly! We hope to be back to this magical place soon. "

"Facilities so beautiful, peaceful and impeccably clean. staff were all amazing... Terese, JoJo, Helena, Martin, Justin... all top notch.. friendly, helpful and professional! We had one little issue that our bathroom window wouldnt open, and it was fixed in an instant after asking. It was quiet as we were in early November, but would be such a beautiful place to celebrate a wedding, special occasion or just to get away Gorgeous beach that goes on forever and beautiful pink sunsets. We loved our stay at this little treasure!!"

"Très bel environnement / un vrai petit paradis Le logement est tout proche des plages Superbes plages de sables fin côté Atlantique Très bon contact avec l’hôte jethro Je recommande / Merci Dominique "

"NOT a resort. But, a wonderful location with beautiful views. Bring your own foodstuffs. Including salt and pepper…not going to find it here. WiFi was intermittent, power went off our first day here for three hours. Very close to Governor’s Harbour and GH airport."

"Excellent"