Search Vacation Homes in Shelter Island Heights

"This was the BEST decision for our family. The house was very cozy, old charm feel with some modern updates. The downstairs bathroom had a Spa vibe. We loved the 6 bedrooms & spacious kitchen & dining room. Loved how close it was to food & entertainment. The walk to the beach was only 10 minutes & very safe. We are use to blinds and/or shades, so just having light curtains for the windows was"

"The house was nice and cozy. When we first arrived, we didn't realize the reference to driveway parking did not mean the driveway on the side of the house. The parking is in front of the house and very convenient. Unfortunately, we had a cold, rainy weekend so we didn't get to hang outside. However, we had a great time indoors playing games and watching movies. The house had tons of amenities from board games to bowls and platters for putting out snacks for game night. The bedrooms are a nice...

"We loved our stay! The location was perfect for our family, so easy to walk to town, close to the beach and easy to get to other towns. House was perfect as well, we didn’t get to enjoy the outdoors due to rain but loved the indoor space. Plenty of places to hang and enjoy/relax. Hoping to visit again soo!"

"The property is nicely located on the water and convenient to many attractions. "

"The house was everything we needed for a weekend away! The house was very clean and cute esthetics. The back yard was great for the dogs. Claudea gave us great recommendations for places to eat. We would def rebook this house! "

"Lovely to be away in a spot just hidden enough to be accessible from the main road but not close to it. Near to the beach but not on top of it. Perfect! Quiet, woody, peaceful, restful and pet friendly. A hidden gem. The only thing I regret is not having time to stay longer."

"Great home"

"Perfect spot for a girls weekend! Property/house as advertised, and the house was fully stocked with all amenities. Thanks for a wonderful stay!! "

"Super responsive host. Stayed in the offseason so pool was closed but was super quiet and the ocean is so close. "

"Very fun location near the beach. Beach is small but really a nice place to be. House worked well for our family of 4. Sun room was very nice."

"Tuvimos un finde increíble en la casa, súper cómoda y bonita "

"We had such a great experience here! Joseph was so gracious and responsive and went above and beyond to make our stay great. His place is so cute with a mix of whimsical and really convenient touches. Our dog loved the yard, too! The neighborhood is gorgeous, too. We wished we had more time to explore the area and to take advantage of all the house has to offer. "