Search Vacation Homes in Pine Island

"Fishing/Lake: There is absolutely no access to the lake, including the community beach. No swimming. No fishing. Such details must be in the property's details in caps. Fishing or swimming is not allowed. Water: Smelly brown water in the house. You can’t drink it or cook with it or even take a shower. It is disguising. No heads-up about the water issue. Kitchen: The smell of dirty dishes welcomed us. It looks like the previous renters left them there. Only 4 forks and 1 knife in the house....

"When we arrived at the house it was just like the photos. We enjoyed the whole house. The fireplace added some romance to our evenings. We felt very comfortable as soon as we walked in. The neighborhood was very nice and quiet. The view of the lake from the deck was great. Thank you very much for the beautiful house."

"This home was just what our group of 16 needed to find rest, reconvene from the day’s activities, and prepare for all the next day’s activities. The town of Monroe was a great place to stay as it was centrally located for all the places we visited. "

"I reserved the house for a family reunion of about 20 people and had a great time. What I really liked about coming here:1. The house - It was spacious and elegant, had multiple living rooms, and had many bathrooms. This was perfect for our large group.2. The grounds - Although we did not use the tennis or pickleball courts because of the weather, we could see how nice it is to have right next to the house. Folks from our group went walking and running on the roads around the house and those...

"We were looking for a weekend in on the lake to relax and unwind and we got exactly that. The house was beautiful, clean and well maintained. Cheryl was attentive and came to help when needed. The views of the lake were breathtaking. Couldn’t have picked a better place. We can’t wait to come back! Thank you! "

"We enjoyed our stay! Very spacious, bigger than the pictures make it seem! Nice large backyard with a good amount of privacy. "

"We stay every holiday season to be near some family who live in the area and by far this has been the nicest house we’ve stayed. It was exceptionally clean quiet and comfortable. Perfect for multiple families. Would most definitely recommend to anyone looking in for a place to stay in the Goshen area. "

"We absolutely loved this cabin! It was so cozy and the perfect size. We had a blast!"

"The house was an older cute home. Very comfortable and inviting. The owner Tony was very easy to talk with and a great communicator. The kitchen is lovely and had plenty of things for your need. We really enjoyed our stay! 😊"

"My partner and I stayed here for a quiet weekend getaway and it was perfect. The home was cozy and welcoming. Enjoyed the snow fall and picturesque view of the frozen lake. Would definitely book again."

"We had such a great little family vacation here. It has beautiful lakes views in every room of the house. The host was beyond wonderful. There was more than enough linens, the kitchen was fully stocked with all amenities and the house was immaculately clean. We will be returning in the summer! "

"This multi-level house is literally right next to the water. It feels like you are hovering over the water. There are incredible views from every floor and lots of outdoor seating to enjoy every angle. Seven of us stayed here for 3 nights and loved every minute of it. The beds are comfortable, the kitchen is well stocked, and the long deck provides access for fishing, a boat rental, and space just to lounge. Jeany was extremely helpful and very responsive. There are some spots in the house that...