Find all hotels by Independent in South Setauket, NY from AED 404

"Another great stay at The Circle. Rooms are spacious, clean and the staff is friendly and helpful. This is our go-to when we visit our son who goes to school in Fairfield. Needed an early check in as we come in on a red-eye and got charged $40USD so that is our only complaint."

"Friendly staff "

"staff very friendly, very clean"

"We stayed for 1 night because we had a wedding to go to close by. This place was really nice, decent breakfast, and was clean. The only thing was there seemed to be an issue with the elevators. Only 1 was working and it seemed the door was nit osong properly on our floor. Other than that everything else was great. "

"Really enjoyed our recent stay at the Hilton Garden Inn! I have to give a special shoutout to Jimmy at the front desk. He went above and beyond to make us feel comfortable. He takes pride in his work and always found a way to do it with a smile and some humor! Breakfast in the lobby was a hit as well! Thanks for making it a wonderful trip to Long Island!"

"I like my stay nice and clean and quiet"

"Excellent stay.,,they allowed us to check in early. What a life saver! Very happy with the accommodations Would stay here again in a minute!!!!"

"Nice "

"Great stay "