Find all hotels by Independent in Newcomerstown, OH from AED 275

"Nice clean, nice breakfast "

"Quaint and very clean. Staff are very friendly. Easy access for those with mobility issues- wide hallways, very open feel. The price was very fair for what you get- it’s not “La-De-Da,” but rather a very practical place that offers uniquely decorated rooms that are comfy and clean. "

"Location"

"Very nice room for the money"

"Nice breakfast, great room with recliners, we stayed three nights, staff very helpful . Room clean, bed comfortable, loved the little dining area in room Everything we needed."

"Very nice hotel, clean modern. A "

" We have stayed at the Carlisle Inn at Sugarcreek several times, and have always had a wonderful experience. The front desk is so welcoming, and every staff member you meet is friendly and helpful. The rooms are spacious and comfortable, and the bathrooms are always spotless! The Inn has beautiful and comfortable Amish made beds. Complimentary cookies, popcorn, coffee, tea and hot chocolate are available in the dining area every evening, and each morning you are treated to a breakfast buffet. the restaurant and bakery next door has delicious Amish meals. And not to miss is the gift shop and the Ohio Star Theater across the parking lot. We saw a Collin Raye show last night that was absolutely awesome. So nice to just walk across the parking lot and head into the Inn. We will definitely be returning!"

"Very well maintained property."

"We absolutely loved our stay! We wish we would have stayed longer! The staff was so nice and our room was absolutely amazing! We had a massage chair, king bed, and heated toilet seats! We were so pleasantly surprised! Absolutely recommend and would love to come back even though we have a 4 hour drive! Great experience much better than a hotel!!"