Search Vacation Homes in Montauk

"This was my first time renting a home and I must say, the entire process was flawless! Communication with Ernie was wonderful as he answered all my questions prior to my stay. The pictures of the home did not do it justice as it was more spacious, clean and beautiful than I expected. It was very close to town as well as the wedding venue and church. I didn't want to leave the home and would love to return! I definitely recommend this home!"

"We had a great stay in Ditch Plains. Definitely recommend this property."

"My family and I stay few days at Jessica house and had a very good experience. Jessica was very responsive to answer our questions. The house was confortable and well stocked. "

"This was our second year staying at Steve’s for an annual fishing trip. Once again, accommodations were great. The home was clean, well appointed and the grounds were impeccably maintained. The location is ideal, as it’s centrally located and convenient, yet offers privacy at the same time. We’re already looking forward to next year."

"Property was very nice. Wish the pool was heated - on sunny days no big deal but on cloudy days pretty cold."

"Deck was very dangerous, nails sticking up, rotting planks, all painted over to hide poor and dangerous condition. Also, no night lighting at hot tub. Interior was clean."

"We had a great time - this house is literally close to everything you would want to see and do in Mtk. House is big and fireplace made it cozy, I loved the heated floor in the mud room. We didn't cook at the house but we did coffee in the morning and relaxed in the big kitchen and wine in the evening before heating to dinner - we really enjoyed the spa at Gurneys too "

"House is even more attractive than the pictures. The upstairs and deck are wonderful spaces to sit, eat and talk. The kitchen was the best of any we have rented. The surrounding trees and hill give it a very secluded feeling. Not only is it a five minute walk to the beach and town, but a trailhead of Shadmoor State Park is a very pleasant 10 minute walk. The trails there along the bluffs have beautiful views of the ocean and beach. We plan on going back next year."

"The house was beautiful and in a gorgeous neighborhood. They even had an outdoor shower! We were so pleased with the place and would highly recommend."

"Melody's house was so enjoyable, in a quiet neighborhood, beautifully renovated with high-end kitchen and bathrooms, light and airy living room. My son is a chef and found the kitchen super well equipped. We've been coming to Montauk many years and this is the first rental we look forward to repeating!"