Find all hotels by Independent in Vineyard Haven, MA

"It was a trip for self healing. The room was beautiful, staff was friendly, I will definitely be back!"

"They have an indoor pool which is small but well maintained. It's right next to the Whaling Museum and our room had a great view of the harbor with all the fishing boats. It's the largest fishing center in the US!"

"Location and the Friendliness of staff. Great amenities as well! "

"Fantastic stay and the property was better than i expected... But indoor pool could use some reconfiguring... Preferably a deep end added..."

"Great room, great service "

"I love that place"

"Newly renovated, and quality of Pam "

"Upon departing the Martha's Vineyard ferry from Vineyard Haven, we drove less than 15 minutes to the Edgar Hotel. The staff were welcoming, hospitable, and helpful with suggestions for places of interest to visit. The room was new, spacious, clean with a comfortable bed, and was quiet except for the exit door near our room that would slam shut and wake us up at 5:30 AM. Our corner room had many windows that offered natural light, however, we were on the first floor and cars parked outside our window could see in if we had the blinds open. The only thing missing are black out curtains. The shower faucet was difficult to turn off if you have arthritis. These are minor things in comparison to the convenient location next to Stop and Shop market, ample parking, and close proximity to all the shops, restaurants, and beach. We will gladly reserve a room here again next time we visit. "

"This property was absolutely amazing! I’ve never experienced a more friendly and welcoming team—everyone was incredible. Pete especially went above and beyond, helping us plan the perfect itinerary for each day of our trip. The property itself is stunning—every detail is thoughtfully designed, and the overall vibe is just perfect. Highly recommend!"