Search Cabin Rentals in Stillwater

Plan, book, stay with confidence

Be picky

Search almost a million properties worldwide

Treat yourself

Change your mind

Book hotels with free cancellation

Compare 38 Cabin Rentals in Stillwater with updated reviews, rates, and availability.

"My wife and I love the Sugarcreek area, and chose The Lodge to spend a long Anniversary weekend. Such a great choice. The hosts Doug and Jen were the best. The Lodge was so peaceful and quiet. Loved the wood burning fireplace on cold late fall nights. If you love nature, a quiet and peaceful location, great Amish food and a fun shopping experience, this place is for you. "

"Cozy cabin. Decorated for Christmas! We will definitely be back!"

"I absolutely love this property. The cabin is unbelievable! So neat to stay in such a historic little nook. I loved the simple and accurate decor. The fresh eggs, muffins, fruit and snacks were such a nice little bonus. Highly recommend staying here and hope to be back myself!"

"We stayed sweetest day weekend was beautiful out, great fires both nights .Then when we left out on Sunday to the Wilds then went to wheeling to cabelas before going home Thank you , and how soon would I have to book it again in august please?"

"Orginally from the area but living out of state, we booked this place to be able to get our friends and family together for my husband's birthday. The long driveway gave us privacy and plenty of parking. The open layout also gave us ALOT of space to mingle. Would book again."

"Didnt want to leave. So we stayed every week for a month!"

"We really enjoyed our stay. Ended up adding an extra night the day before we were scheduled to leave. Only 15 minutes to nearest town. Quiet. Secluded. We used the fire pit and fireplace which I loved. Would stay again, maybe in the summer next time. Thanks for an amazing holiday! Rog and Amy"

AED 569 total

includes taxes & fees

27 Dec - 28 Dec

"The cabin was adorable but I didn’t realize the two person cabin had no bathroom. We were at the top of the hill and had to drive downhill to the bath house. Would have been nice to have a bathroom at least near our cabin to use at night. Also it was a surprise for the $200 deposit to come out the day before our arrival in addition to what we paid. Everything was clean and nice other than that."

AED 569 total

includes taxes & fees

27 Dec - 28 Dec

Winter Wonderland for hiking, sledding or cross-country skiing. Can you dig it?

"Nice quite location. Hoping to return again sometime. "

"Perfect weekend getaway!"

"These host(s) have again been professional and accommodating. We just had our 3rd stay and love staying at Sarah and Nick's 4pelicans cabin; as it continues to have all the comforts of home and more. Leesville Lake certainly helps us slowdown and enjoy the natural wonders that nature has to offer."

AED 569 total

includes taxes & fees

27 Dec - 28 Dec

"Long weekend getaway with friends staying at the RV campground. Short drive to the park, close to lakefront restaurant and boat rentals, nice property with plenty of amenities. Overall relaxing stay and an enjoyable day on the water."

AED 841 total

includes taxes & fees

29 Dec - 30 Dec

"I booked this property to celebrate my wife for graduating her Master Program, and brought our tri-pod for the weekend. We had an amazing time! The whole stay was beautiful, from the lake to the inside of The Olive. The correspondence was impressive, answering any questions I had within hours! We will definitely be coming back!"

AED 1,877 total

includes taxes & fees

9 Jan - 10 January 2025

"Just wanted to get away and do a little fishing, Very Quiet in The Arcadia A-Frame. "

AED 569 total

includes taxes & fees

27 Dec - 28 Dec

"A hidden gem! Loved it! "

"Very nice"

AED 841 total

includes taxes & fees

29 Dec - 30 Dec

"So peaceful! Property is beautiful. Short drive into Amish towns. Excellent communication! We had an emergency on Friday night and the owner quickly came over to help us. Thanks David! Would highly recommend."