Search Cottages in New Suffolk

"This rental is so unique with the 2 sides, and was absolutely perfect for our wedding weekend. We had the groom’s friends staying on one side, and my friends staying on the other side. The two sides are connected through the sunroom and the backyard space is great which made bringing the whole group together so easy. The setup was also perfect for me to get ready on my own separate side the day of the wedding so that my now husband wouldn’t see me. The decor and cleanliness of the house were...

"Before my trip even began, communication with Bill was exceptional. Bill was very responsive throughout my entire 3 day stay. The entire house was recently renovated, and I can tell not only did they invest a lot of money in the renovation, but they were very thoughtful in all the upgrades they made. The neighborhood is also very peaceful. Whether you make a left or right, you’re only a couple blocks from the beach. My wife and I really enjoyed staying at this house. It was perfect for us as a...

"We stayed for the weekend and couldn't have had a better time! The home is clean and lovely with a well stocked kitchen, comfortable beds and an unbeatable views! Very close to wineries, downtown Greenport and the Shelter Island ferry. Patrick, the owner, had great tips on local activities and was an all around great guy. Thank you! We'll be back! Patrick"

"Stay was relaxing, space was very cozy. we enjoyed our stay. "

"We had an amazing time enjoying the house and exploring the area. Fishing wasn’t fantastic, but that’s nobody’s fault. Would definitely go back!"

"we had such a fun weekend out in southold! Cottage was perfect for us for a cold rainy weekend. Everything was so close to the house. Will definitely be back in the summer!"

"My family enjoyed staying at this lovely property. The backyard was especially great! My kids splashed in the heated pool and jumped on the trampoline every day! The location was ideal and very close to the beach. We would definitely return. "