Search Cottages in New Haven

"If you are good with an authentic rustic environment- complete with small rodent catch and release trap under the stairs, a little water coming in the bedroom ceiling when it rains, bugs galore, and supplying your own drinking water— then OK. Everyone else consider yourselves forewarned. There has been absolutely no maintenance done on this property in decades. The local staff are wonderful."

"My wife and I really enjoyed our stay. The home was lovingly restored and attention to detail was evident both in the house and the grounds. The stonework and outdoor spaces are spectacular."

"Great place for friends and family to gather."

"The view of the lake is gorgeous, and the house felt like a home in every way. The beds were comfortable and the living room spacious. It was a great setting to visit with our family. "

"The property itself, along with the staff were fantastic! The island has great trails, and our dog had a blast. Getting to and from the island is pretty smooth - ferry drivers were usually ready in a couple minutes time. Couple things to note - the check-in information we received was a little sparse relative to other stays via VRBO. If you're used to getting an access code, you won't for this property. And teh driving directions, while good once you've got your bearings, are not great for...

"We were very excited to arrive at this beautiful location, however, the listing doesn't accurately describe this rental. Be aware that the windows don't close properly (or at all), there is a lot of noise during the night, properly critters. This unit is above someone and the neighbors are quite close. Very nice ferry driver! If you are into a glamping experience, it is worth it, but the price should reflect this."

"An incredible Lakeside cottage, easy access to the water, boats to play with and very very friendly staff"

"The Island is lovely. House was not as clean as it could have been. Caretakers were very nice and accommodating. Lake amenities were terrific."