Find Romantic Hotels in Long Island

"This was a great resort with 2 beautiful beaches. Views and cottages are spectacular. The best parts of my stay was the amazing hospitality and delicious food. I highly recommended this resort. You can tell they pride themselves on hospitality."

"The beach was amazing and I loved the location of the hotel. We were able to walk to the supermarket that was directly across the street from the main entrance. Overall I had a great experience."

"We had a great stay at Ocean Point! This hotel was perfect given the cost and it was nice to be on the beach with a pool. The staff is incredibly friendly and the hotel is clean."

"We loved our room; so much space and the views were magnificent. It is a long haul up a steep hotel, but the staff are there with golf buggies to ferry you up and down. It is noisy however late evenings, mainly due to the sports bar next door, but the only real problem was Karaoke night! Hotel does provide ear plugs if you want an early, quiet night. NO food onsite, but plenty of cafes, restaurants and bars close by."

"We liked how calm and relaxing this resort was. The staff was friendly. The food was decent. Unfortunately it was very windy while we were there (Feb 2025) so some of the things we could do in the ocean were limited but that's not the fault of the resort. We really enjoyed our stay. The fitness center was top tier. Pools, rooms and beach clean. We really have no complaint with our stay and would return. "

"Cocobay was perfect. The resort is gorgeous, the staff is so kind and helpful and always willing to go out of their way to serve you. The food was fantastic, and the little cottages were so quaint and always clean. We would definitely go back!"

"Great location, right on the beach. There was always sun beds available by the pool and daily housekeeping if you wanted it. Good local restaurants. We will be back! "

"Amazing low key atmosphere. Beautiful beaches. Not a party place. "

"Amazing staff and food! Property is beautiful with various pockets of different spaces so, while smallish, the resort really expands with options depending on where you choose to spend a particular day."