Find Historic Hotels in Cape May, NJ

"We appreciated how quiet it was inside the rooms! "

"We thoroughly enjoyed our stay. What a beautiful property."

"amazing "

"Great place, great view! Would stay there again."

"What a pleasant surprise. Rooms are beautifully decorated, bed is super comfortable, loved that we had a full refrigerator/freezer and a microwave. Cute pool out front, convenient parking, and a short drive to all we wanted to do. Will definitely come back and recommend"

"The Beach Shack is a nice spot to stay at when in Cape May. Pros : Ample parking, great location, restaurant on site, easy check in & texting abilities with front desk/hospitality/concierge, clean & nice layout. Cons : Lacks coziness for that surfer vibe theyre going for - could use more ocean/surfer artwork decor & not enough mirrors or hooks. "

"A great place and proximity to the beach and walking distance to town centered mall. Staff was the best. You won’t be disappointed."

"Room was bigger than expected and you can’t beat the location."

"A very clean and more intimate way of staying in Cape May than the big grand resorts or the motels. I found it both very peaceful (1-2 min walk from the beach) and in the heart of things (equally close to most of the excellent food places and shops in the area). The innkeeper was fantastic. I never use concierge services while travelling but touched base with her twice a day as a solo traveler new to the area simply because she was so helpful and kind without being overbearing. The café is enough to grab a quick meal or drink if needed but small enough not to disturb you with foot traffic noise if you're in the rooms above it during operational hours. Everything was cleaned to my liking. If you like cozy, you'll like this place, if you like sleek modernism or minimalistic interiors this isn't the place for that. I loved it, it was very 'Cape May' and tastefully done. This was honestly an absolute dream of a place for me - I could never afford it if I hadn't stayed in the off-season, but the service was top-tier anyway and if I ever have the money, I'm staying here for a week minimum."