Find 2 Star Hotels in Fishers Island, NY from AED 172

"Pros- Comfortable beds, clean, friendly staff, breakfast included, convenient location & quiet. Cons- Pool not heated and closes too early, no hot tub (I know its not listed under amenities - however was listed as a top review), remote turned on tv but did not change channels. Overall it was a good experience. The cons are very minimal and really just listed for those that find these things important. I'd stay here again."

"Under new management and they were very helpful, polite, and seem to be moving the hotel in a great direction. The building, rooms and pool were all updated since last time I was there a few years ago and the hotel itself is in a perfect location. I highly recommend staying here. "

"Updated rooms, bed was comfortable, amazing staff"

"Right off the highway. Very safe. Very close to the aquarium. That was the reason for our stay"

"Staff was very nice and room nice and clean. "

"Is a good place"

"Did not like nothing "

"Wonderful breakfast included and hot coffee & hot chocolate all day with toppings for the kids to indulge… receptionists were excellent.. very pleased with everything "

"Was an excellent place really clean a quick check in; nice location easy in and out of the Highway. "

"This was a great stay. Good water pressure in the shower. Ample parking. Great staff. Comfortable bed. The only thing I didn’t like was that it was February and when I got into my room, it was very cold. Like 60° maybe. I put the heat on full blast and about 2 hours later it was comfortable. I went to the front desk for an extra blanket and they were happy to accommodate. "

"The surrounding property is very nice and quaint. The hotel has a nice lobby with a large telly and comfortable sofas for guests. There are large restrooms in the lobby along with a variety of snack and cold soft drinks to buy. Breakfast is every day from 7 to 10 am. with coffee, juices, a belgium waffle maker with batter, egg omlets, a variety of cold and hot cereal varieties, donuts, breads milks, toasters and a variety of jellies and yogurts. They offer ALL of this everyday. It's delicious...

"Good experience. Actually better than I expected. Clean, comfortable, and neat. The fridge was a slim 5 foot one with a freezer and a decent size microwave. Those 2 things are a bonus and both in immaculate condition. The sheets were clean and the bed was made up nice. Bathroom was also clean. I would definitely recommend. The only thing I didn’t like about the room was that the ‘bathroom sink’ is placed outside of the bathroom close to the microwave and counter which was weird to me. "