Search Cottages in Windermere Island

"This house was perfect. Great ocean views on a huge beach. Good central location a few minutes from Governor’s Harbor. Large kitchen and living spaces. A really charming house with plenty of cooling for hot days. Highly recommend."

"The house was beautiful to match the view. It was super clean and well-kept. It was nice to have items like beach towels and a cloth cooler to be able to use. It was easy to find and a perfect distance from Governor's Harbor. We were greeted by the owner, and she later graciously resolved an internet issue. She followed up later to make sure it was still working. In our opinion, this home is located on the prettiest beach of the island. We will certainly be coming back!"

"This was our first trip to the beautiful island of Eleuthera and Eleuthera vacation rentals and our onsite contact Misty were so helpful with planning from beginning to end! They made our trip stress free and we felt well taken care of! From helping me find the perfect flight and finding a boat excursion they were extremely helpful. The Simple Life was perfect for my husband and myself! Just steps from a beautiful beach! Stocked with everything you need and the beach chairs, umbrella and...

"My boyfriend and I had an amazing time at chez Cay. The hosts were the Best! Erika and Scott! They answered us each and every time we needed anything. They gave us suggestions on where to see music and get good food! Scott showed us how to gut Konch shells! In was such a cool experience. The house was very cozy and the views and sunsets were unbeatable:) we highly recommend this place. Thank again for everything! Cheers until next time 😁"

"Great location, lovely property. John is super helpful, friendly and accommodating. We had a great time in Eleuthera."

"This is a very nice house in a good location. While it is not waterfront there is a good view of the Atlantic from the front porch and easy access to central Eleuthera - Governors Harbor, James Cistern, and many beaches on both the Atlantic and Caribbean. The house itself is spacious, modern and well-maintained. Large double doors on the front of the house provided cooling breezes both day and night. The owner was very responsive to our very few needs."

"Beautiful property, and beach. Well maintained. Great location for easy day trips to the north or south of the island."

"Would go again "

"My husband and I had an amazing stay. There was a slight mix up upon our arrival and the house was not ready for us when we arrived, but Lachadra came over immediately to help and we were able to stay at the larger property next door for a night which was nice. Orchid Cottage was the perfect size for my husband and I and had all the necessary amenities. We spent our time exploring the island via the rental car provided. Someone met us at the airport with the car and it was extremely convenient...

"Property was clean, comfortable and spacious. Location was fine if you had a vehicle. Although the beach was nice, it wasn't really good for swimming. But to be fair, the tide was out when we went."

"Alex’s both ages are super modern and clean. They are a few steps from one of the prettiest beaches on Eleuthera. Alex was a wonderful host and the property is all newly-appointed. Highly recommend!"