Stayed for a weekend and had a great time. House is beautiful, lots of charm, fully equipped, and on a nice property. Relatively easy to access from the Pawling Metro North station, so we didn't need to rent a car, which was great!
The only downside is that the property is on two roads which are a bit busy; if it weren't for that, I would definitely have given it 5 stars. The roads are NOT a deal breaker and we still had a relaxing weekend, but if you're looking for something really secluded, this isn't your best bet.
Finally, Alison was a terrific host. Extremely helpful, kind, and responsive. Thanks!