Search Villas in Middle Cay

    Plan, book, stay with confidence
    bex rewards loyalty icon
    Be picky
    Search almost a million properties worldwide
    payments icon
    Treat yourself
    Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
    today icon
    Change your mind
    Book hotels with free cancellation

Compare 32 Villas in Middle Cay with updated reviews, rates, and availability.

Eleuthera Villa - The Surfer's Beach Destination!
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (26)
"We will be back, Todd and/or Mary were absolutely incredible hosts. Reading the travel planner is essential and the description on VRBO so you won’t be surprised by bugs or power outages on island. The biggest advice I would give is to bring plenty of cash there are only 2 ATMs we could find on island and one did not work on one of our cards. Almost no one takes cards. This was a challenge at first but if i would have doubled my cash I brought i would have been fine:) this island has so much...
Eleuthera Villa - The Surfer's Beach Destination!
Complimentary Concierge + Private Beaches + Gaulding Cay + Chef Services + Pool
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (9)
"The most wonderful place we have ever stayed. The staff was so helpful and courteous. The property was so beautiful and well maintained. Our family had the best time."
Complimentary Concierge + Private Beaches + Gaulding Cay + Chef Services + Pool
Private Beach, Dock Breathtaking Waterfront Private Luxury Estate Property
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (2)
"Words can’t express how unbelievable Beacon Hill is to visit! The entire process was flawless from start to finish. My wife and I love Harbour Island and this is one of the very best properties ! We look forward to making more memories in the future staying at Beacon Hill. The owners are beyond accommodating and keep the home in perfect condition. Island life at its best !"
Private Beach, Dock Breathtaking Waterfront Private Luxury Estate Property
Beautiful beachfront villa situated on the famous pink sand beach!
8.8 out of 10, Excellent, (6)
"Excellent stay with perfect weather in a beautiful home directly on the beach You can not beat this place !"
Beautiful beachfront villa situated on the famous pink sand beach!
Villa in Secluded Whale Point
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (4)
"Baycienda is truly magical. Tom, Brenda and Sanchez are wonderful. Pack your bathing suit and sunblock and be prepared to spend your time on the water with Sanchez. Your mornings will start with the sun rise from your window, and end with the sunset over the Caribbean."
Villa in Secluded Whale Point
Complimentary Concierge + Private Beaches & Pool + Chef Services + King Suites
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (8)
"It is hard for words to describe the Villa, except it was so incredible. The Villa was first class (Villa 2), the location and privacy was delightful. The beach was beautiful, along with the pools. Not to mention the on site Butler that would check in with you each day, set up your beach or pool supplies and the Chef would cook anything that you desired. We will be back!!!!"
Complimentary Concierge + Private Beaches & Pool + Chef Services + King Suites
Complimentary Concierge + Private Beach + Gaulding Cay + Chef Services
9.8 out of 10, Exceptional, (7)
"Staff was very attentive. Property was striking. Our villa was kept very clean. Beach was beautiful and quiet with calm, warm water and extensive shallow sand bars. The chef prepared some very nice meals. There is one colorful local restaurant within walking distance. The location is pretty isolated. There are taxis on call but getting off the property isn’t very convenient without a car. A great place for a very quiet, secluded and restful stay. "
Complimentary Concierge + Private Beach + Gaulding Cay + Chef Services
Oceanfront Private Romantic Easy Water Access on Caribbean Sea Couples Retreat
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (25)
"The house is everything and more. The views are amazing, the house has everything that anyone would need. The owners and caretaker are very responsive. Will definitely rent this home again."
Oceanfront Private Romantic Easy Water Access on Caribbean Sea Couples Retreat
Home overlooking Gregory Town's famous Cove. Beach chairs and SUP included
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (4)
"The property is large, well-equipped, beautifully positioned/located and is a joy to stay in. The owners are so friendly are helpful and worked hard to deal with any issues during our stay. I wholeheartedly recommend it!"
Home overlooking Gregory Town's famous Cove. Beach chairs and SUP included
Sweet Bahama Blue - Spanish Wells, Bahamas COMING 2025!
2.0 star property
Sweet Bahama Blue - Spanish Wells, Bahamas COMING 2025!
Caribbean Haven: Secluded Retreat With Stunning Ocean Views
4.0 star property
Caribbean Haven: Secluded Retreat With Stunning Ocean Views
Paradise Cove: Oceanfront Haven With Infinity Pool
4.0 star property
Paradise Cove: Oceanfront Haven With Infinity Pool
Harbour Island Haven: Newly Remodeled Cottage Near Pink Sands Beach
4.0 star property
Harbour Island Haven: Newly Remodeled Cottage Near Pink Sands Beach
Historical Charm: Restored Historic Home With Pool
4.0 star property
Historical Charm: Restored Historic Home With Pool
Secluded Luxury: New Beachfront Home With Pool
4.0 star property
Secluded Luxury: New Beachfront Home With Pool
Refuge By The Sea: Tranquil Cottage
4.0 star property
Refuge By The Sea: Tranquil Cottage
Seaside Escape: Luxury Beach House With Ocean Views
4.0 star property
Seaside Escape: Luxury Beach House With Ocean Views
Ultra-Luxury Escape: New Beachfront Villa
4.0 star property
Ultra-Luxury Escape: New Beachfront Villa
Villa Oasis: Newly Remodeled Luxury Villa With Pool & Private Garden
4.0 star property
Villa Oasis: Newly Remodeled Luxury Villa With Pool & Private Garden
Island Serenity: Charming Watercolor Cottage Near Beach
4.0 star property
Island Serenity: Charming Watercolor Cottage Near Beach
Don't see what you're looking for?
See all available properties in Middle Cay
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Other property types in Middle Cay

Bamboo House: Charming Private Tropical Oasis in the Heart of the Village.
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (52)
"Charming and comfortable home. Close to beach and restaurants. Beautiful garden and nice pool to come home to after a long day at beach."
Bamboo House: Charming Private Tropical Oasis in the Heart of the Village.
Chatterbox. An Island Home in the Heart of Harbour Island.
9.0 out of 10, Wonderful, (26)
"Chatterbox is a beautiful well kept house. It's ideally and centrally located; everything is within walking distance. It's close to the beach, supermarket, wine and liquor stores, top restaurants, bakeries and local conch and fish shacks. Service was super and communication channels with the host was excellent. No question was too insignificant to answer. The house was clean and fully furnished with top of the line appliances and amenities. We will definitely be back!"
Chatterbox. An Island Home in the Heart of Harbour Island.
Coral Cove sleeps 2 adults 1 child FREE 4 seater golf cart and 1 kayak 1 sup
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (162)
"We absolutely LOVEDthis place. Perfect little secluded cove with Sandbar few steps away. April and Tyson are amazing hosts and we have already told so many people about this tental and this beautiful island where everyone makes you feel at home. We took a fishing charter on their Tyman boat with Reuben. He was so much fun! . Such a great time and caught lots of fish that we cooked at the house. Cant wait to visit again soon! amazing hosts and made everything easy for us by takin"
Coral Cove sleeps 2 adults 1 child FREE 4 seater golf cart and 1 kayak 1 sup
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.