First of all, I did enjoy my stay at Eleuthera very much! It is the perfect island for a getaway and the beaches are incredible! The local people are very nice and helpful. However, it seems that all the unfriendly people work at the Eleuthera Yacht Resort.
When we checked in into our room one curtain was broken, the light in my room didn´t work and we had ants in our ice cooler. I won´t say anything about the kitchen stuff (pans, pots, etc.) because it isn´t worth it. We asked the staff to fix the curtain and light right after we discovered them on the very same day, and they said they would fix it. But they didn´t. They had 6 days time (althoug they said they would fix it on the next day).
And the food at their so-called "restaurant" is a joke, especially for the prices they charge. The highlight was the pizza, which, according to the menu, was to be prepared from their chef with fresh ingredients. The pizza was clearly a frozen pizza, and not even finished. It tasted like they threw it into the microwave for 2 minutes and then served it. But at least they charged 16$ for it.
I can definetely recommend a stay at Eleuthera, but stay at another hotel.