This property worked well for us as a retired couple returning to the area where we once lived. The host was very responsive to early "minor" issues we experienced. The townhome was quite spacious for the 2 of us, was exceptionally clean and nicely decorated. It was obvious the host spent time updating and renovating this unit. The kitchen was well stocked with dishes, cookware, etc.
Amenities we would have liked was a garbage disposal, an ice maker in the freezer (it was actually a very modern refrigerator, but no ice maker), a toaster oven (it had just a toaster) and a more easily accessible refuse/recycling center (needed to take it in our car to a center about a block away).
The location to the lake was a bit further than we expected and somewhat of a hassle to get to. It was reportedly a 9 minute walk, but you had to walk along a busy road to another road, then down a hill and to an elevator. It wasn't worth going.
It's about a 20 minute car ride into Canandaigua which was not a problem for us.
Overall, we would definitely recommend this vacation rental; the only reason for 4, instead of 5 stars, was what we mentioned above (and those factors may not be that important to others).